The 10 Best Fan Expansion Board Games You Need to Try

Board games are a fantastic way to bring friends and family together, and when it comes to enhancing the gaming experience, fan expansion boards are the secret ingredient. These expansions add depth, variety, and new mechanics to your favorite games. Here, we’ll explore the ten best fan expansion board games that can transform your gaming nights.

1. Terraforming Mars: Prelude

Description: Terraforming Mars: Prelude is a well-loved fan expansion for the original Terraforming Mars game. This expansion introduces new Prelude cards that provide players with unique starting resources and advantages, setting the stage for more strategic gameplay. With these new cards, players can customize their starting conditions, adding a layer of variability and replayability. The expansion also includes new project cards that add more options and combinations for players to explore. One of the standout features of Prelude is its ability to shorten the game setup time while still maintaining the depth of the original game.

Pros: Prelude adds a layer of strategy right from the beginning of the game, offering players more control over their starting conditions. The new project cards provide fresh and engaging options.

Cons: Some players might find the new cards overwhelming or disruptive if they prefer the original balance of the game.

Key Features:

• Number of Players: 1-5
• Playing Time: 90-120 minutes
• Complexity: Medium

Buy on Amazon

2. Gloomhaven: Forgotten Circles

Description: Forgotten Circles is a fan expansion for the critically acclaimed Gloomhaven. This expansion introduces a new character class, the Sentinel, who brings a unique playstyle with a focus on defense and area control. Forgotten Circles also adds new scenarios and enemies, providing fresh challenges for experienced players. The expansion integrates seamlessly with the base game, offering a deeper narrative and more tactical options. One of the most praised aspects of Forgotten Circles is how it enhances the cooperative experience with its new mechanics and story elements.

Pros: The new Sentinel class adds a fresh dynamic to the gameplay, and the additional scenarios keep the game exciting and unpredictable.

Cons: As with many expansions, it may increase the complexity of the game, which could be daunting for new players.

Key Features:

• Number of Players: 1-4
• Playing Time: 60-120 minutes per scenario
• Complexity: High

Buy on Amazon

3. Catan: Seafarers

Description: Catan: Seafarers expands the classic Catan experience by introducing naval exploration to the game. Players can now build ships and explore new islands, adding a maritime layer to the resource management and trading mechanics of the base game. The expansion includes new scenarios and additional victory points through maritime achievements. Seafarers enhances the strategic depth of Catan, offering a fresh experience for veteran players while remaining accessible to newcomers.

Pros: The addition of ships and new islands introduces new strategies and expands the board, keeping the game engaging.

Cons: The expansion might slightly increase the game setup time and complexity compared to the base game.

Key Features:

• Number of Players: 3-4
• Playing Time: 60-120 minutes
• Complexity: Medium

Buy on Amazon

4. 7 Wonders: Leaders

Description: Leaders is an expansion for the popular game 7 Wonders, focusing on adding influential leaders to the game. These leaders provide unique abilities and bonuses, which players can leverage to develop their civilizations more effectively. The expansion introduces a new draft phase where players choose their leaders, adding an extra layer of strategy to the game. Leaders also enhances the replayability of 7 Wonders by providing different strategic options based on the leader’s abilities.

Pros: The ability to choose leaders adds strategic depth and variability to each game session.

Cons: Some players might find the new draft phase slightly overwhelming or disruptive to their usual gameplay.

Key Features:

• Number of Players: 2-7
• Playing Time: 30-45 minutes
• Complexity: Medium

Buy on Amazon

5. Arkham Horror: The Dunwich Legacy

Description: The Dunwich Legacy is an expansion for Arkham Horror: The Card Game that delves into Lovecraftian horror with a series of new scenarios set in the eerie town of Dunwich. The expansion introduces new investigators, monsters, and locations, enriching the game’s thematic depth. Players must navigate through a gripping narrative, solving mysteries and battling cosmic horrors. The new elements integrate smoothly with the base game, offering an enhanced and immersive experience.

Pros: The expansion provides a rich narrative and thematic depth, enhancing the overall horror experience.

Cons: The complexity of the new scenarios may increase the difficulty of the game, which might not suit all players.

Key Features:

• Number of Players: 1-2
• Playing Time: 60-120 minutes per scenario
• Complexity: High

Buy on Amazon

6. Blood Rage: Gods of Asgard

Description: Gods of Asgard is an expansion for Blood Rage that introduces new gods and divine powers into the game. The expansion adds a new layer of strategy with the inclusion of powerful deity cards that can dramatically alter gameplay. Players can now harness the power of the gods to influence battles and achieve their objectives. The new gods add variety and tactical options, making each game session unique and exciting.

Pros: The addition of gods introduces new strategic elements and can shift the balance of power in unexpected ways.

Cons: The new mechanics might complicate the game for players who prefer the original simpler rules.

Key Features:

• Number of Players: 2-4
• Playing Time: 60-90 minutes
• Complexity: Medium

Buy on Amazon

7. Scythe: The Wind Gambit

Description: The Wind Gambit is an expansion for Scythe that adds airships to the game, along with new tiles and options for exploration. Airships provide players with new abilities and strategic choices, enhancing the depth of the game’s already rich mechanics. The expansion also includes additional encounter cards and a new resolution system, which adds to the game’s replayability. The Wind Gambit integrates seamlessly with the base game, offering fresh challenges and opportunities.

Pros: The introduction of airships adds a unique strategic dimension to the game, and the new components enhance gameplay variety.

Cons: The expansion might increase the game’s complexity and length, which could be a downside for some players.

Key Features:

• Number of Players: 1-7
• Playing Time: 90-120 minutes
• Complexity: Medium

Buy on Amazon

8. Pandemic: On the Brink

Description: On the Brink is an expansion for Pandemic that introduces new roles, events, and challenges. The expansion adds a new bioterrorist challenge that requires players to work together to combat a new, more dangerous threat. On the Brink also includes new player roles and events that can alter the course of the game. This expansion is designed to increase the game’s difficulty and replayability, making it a favorite among fans looking for a tougher challenge.

Pros: The bioterrorist threat introduces a new layer of difficulty, and the new roles add more strategic options.

Cons: The increased difficulty might not appeal to all players, particularly those who prefer the base game’s balance.

Key Features:

• Number of Players: 2-4
• Playing Time: 45-60 minutes
• Complexity: Medium to High

Buy on Amazon

9. Ticket to Ride: Europe

Description: Ticket to Ride: Europe is an expansion that adds new routes, stations, and mechanics to the classic Ticket to Ride game. The European map introduces new gameplay elements such as tunnels, ferries, and stations, which add complexity and strategic depth. The expansion also includes new train cards and destination tickets, expanding the options available to players. Ticket to Ride: Europe enhances the base game’s strategic possibilities and provides a fresh experience for fans of the original.

Pros: The new mechanics and map add variety and depth to the gameplay, enhancing the overall experience.

Cons: The added complexity might make the game less accessible to newcomers.

Key Features:

• Number of Players: 2-5
• Playing Time: 60-120 minutes
• Complexity: Medium

Buy on Amazon

10. Dominion: Intrigue

Description: Dominion: Intrigue is an expansion for the popular deck-building game Dominion, adding new cards and mechanics that enhance the core gameplay. This expansion introduces more interaction between players, with cards that allow for direct competition and strategic planning. Intrigue includes additional victory points and special abilities that can drastically alter game strategy. It is praised for its ability to increase the game’s replayability and depth.

Pros: The new interaction mechanics and cards provide fresh strategies and increased replay value.

Cons: The additional complexity might be overwhelming for players who prefer the simplicity of the base game.

Key Features:

• Number of Players: 2-4
• Playing Time: 30-60 minutes
• Complexity: Medium

Buy on Amazon

Incorporating these fan expansions into your game nights can significantly enrich your tabletop experiences. Whether you’re looking for deeper strategy, new challenges, or just a fresh take on your favorite games, these expansions offer something for every board game enthusiast.